RESERVATION.......

The Dravidian model of public health

The recent Supreme Court judgement upholding the constitutionality of reservation for Other Backward Classes (OBC) in National Eligibility cum Entrance Test (NEET)‘s All-India Quota (AIQ) seats for undergraduate and postgraduate medical and dental courses is a landmark in the history of social justice in the country. “The propriety of actions and dedication to public service should also be seen as markers of merit, which cannot be assessed in a competitive examination,” observed the bench comprising Justice D.Y. Chandrachud and Justice A.S. Bopanna.

In the light of these crucial observations, it is high time that we demystify the narrow definitions of merit. “Merit should be socially contextualised and reconceptualised as an instrument that advances social goods like equality that we as a society value,” the apex court said. In this regard, the practices followed by Tamil Nadu, where the notion of merit has taken into account the role of historical privileges instead of an illusory inborn ability, can be replicated to facilitate social advancement throughout India.

A tectonic shift

Successive Dravidian governments in Tamil Nadu have had a broad and an inclusive understanding of ‘merit’ and its social implications. Hence, affirmative action to provide reservation for in-service doctors has stood the test of time for well over four decades. The introduction of the scheme reserving 50% of the postgraduate and super-specialty medical seats for government doctors ushered in a tectonic shift in providing tertiary health care in government hospitals. It resulted in the expansion of public health infrastructure in the State. This progressive reform paved the way for ensuring the availability of specialists in multiple disciplines such as gynaecology, anaesthesia, general medicine, paediatrics, general surgery and orthopedics, which were scarce in almost every district headquarters hospital across the State 40 years ago. This was complemented by super-specialty departments like Urology, Nephrology, Cardiology and Neurology in the Madras Medical College (MMC) in the 1960s and 1970s. The provision of reservation for government doctors in super-specialty courses contributed to a steady rise in the availability of multi-specialty experts not only in metropolitan cities like Chennai, Coimbatore and Madurai, but also Tier-2 cities as early as the 1990s. Today, the public health sector in Tamil Nadu has 900 super-specialists in different disciplines, a number comparable only to a few European countries.

The unique scheme had a dual effect. It encouraged young MBBS graduates to serve in rural areas, as serving for three years in Primary Health Centres (PHCs) in rural areas is an eligibility criterion for graduates to avail themselves of the reservation policy. As a consequence, State PHCs and government hospitals never witnessed a shortage of doctors and people got better healthcare facilities at their doorsteps.

The healthcare managers in the Tamil Nadu government were not short-sighted while formulating the policy. They unveiled a unique superannuation bond for these government doctors to ensure that those who secure postgraduate or super-specialty seats by availing themselves of in-service reservation will serve the government till their retirement. This legal binding has ensured that a vast majority of the specialists continues their service in the government sector throughout their career. The main aim of this superannuation bond was to prevent the brain drain either to the private sector or to places abroad. It has proved to be a win-win situation for doctors and the government. This unique scheme is present nowhere in the country.

If one attempts an objective analysis of the contribution of two prestigious institutions — MMC and IIT-Madras — where ‘bright’ and ‘meritorious’ students land, in societal advancement and regional development, MMC would shine largely due to its adoption of reformatory policies that are consistent with the societal needs of Tamil Nadu.

A myopic view

However, with the introduction of NEET and Regulation 9 by the Medical Council of India (MCI), the admission policy has undergone a sea change. The weightage for government doctors who serve in rural areas has reduced. The MCI has framed a policy of giving only 50% of postgraduate diploma seats to service doctors, exempting postgraduate degrees. Besides lack of consultation with stakeholders, the policymakers in Delhi are yet to put forth their rationale for this myopic view in the public domain.

Shockingly, the Union government went to the extent of filing affidavits opposing in-service reservation before the Madras High Court and Supreme Court when the new rule was challenged by the Tamil Nadu Medical Officers Association. While the State government rightly says that dismantling incentives to serving doctors would jeopardise healthcare delivery system in the State, the Union government is opposing the very idea by hiding behind the nebulous regulations of MCI, a regulatory watchdog without any legal teeth to formulate policy. With this move, the Union government has put the rural healthcare delivery system in peril and pushed young doctors, who find it difficult to compete with their urban counterparts who have access to niche coaching institutes, out of the system to prepare for competitive exams instead of serving the poor in rural areas.

It is unfortunate that the affidavits filed by the Centre on both the OBC reservation and the government in-service doctors reservation cases in the court are based on a narrow reading of what constitutes merit rather than an inclusive prism called public health. Instead of trying to widen the scope of a time-tested practice, which would ensure robust supply of specialist and super-specialist doctors to strengthen public health care, the Union government is hell bent on unleashing misery. Its lament about the unwillingness of doctors to work in rural areas and its attempt to push them to take up compulsory rural service after MBBS or to introduce a bridge course for AYUSH doctors to incarnate them as rural physicians is purely rhetorical.

In continuation of the maladies of NEET, from 2017, it became compulsory for individual States to surrender all the seats of super-specialty courses to the central pool for common counselling, forgoing the domiciliary needs (15% of MBBS seats, 50% of postgraduate seats but 100% of super-specialty seats are surrendered to Centre, which is known as AIQ) and also abolishing government doctors’ reservation. Disposing of a case filed in the Madras High Court by members of the Service Doctors and Postgraduates Association for the reintroduction of 50% service doctors’ reservation in super-speciality courses, the court has directed the Centre to provide reservation for service doctors in super-specialty courses. Will the Union government act in accordance with the recent judgement of the Supreme Court, which has advocated a broader definition of the concept of merit by facilitating a smooth reintroduction of in-service doctors and domiciliary reservation for respective States in super-specialty courses from the current academic admission year?

Sakthirajan Ramanathan is Assistant Professor of Nephrology, MMC; Sundaresan Chellamuthu is Associate Professor of Radiation Oncology, Tamil Nadu Government Multi Super Specialty Hospital and State president, Government All Doctors Association

Comments

WHAT IS THE MAIN APPEAL .........Need to move with caution

COGNITIVE SKILLS OF ELEPHANT Elephants have been observed using such ‘learned’ skills to either cleverly cross electric fences using their non-conducting tusks or if no tusks, destroying the entire fence by hurling uprooted trees on the wire or pushing down the cemented poles to disconnect the wire. These are some testimonies suggesting how elephants perhaps may be learning to solve the conundrum based on their previous noxious experiences. . WHY WE ARE FORGOTTEN ABOUT SOMETHING People visiting forests feel great about being in nature. They capture some memories and photographs, and write blogs about how splendid nature is. What they forget in the due course is the compromise some of the long-ranging animals must have gone through. One such animal that needs a large roaming space and seasonal connectivity to different forests are elephants. Their movements are not just motivated for foraging, but for searching for mates, suitable habitats across seasons and resources. MAN AN...

A GLIMPSE OF ONE OF THE FIRST LOVE.......

True spirit amongst aspirants TUMHE DEKHA TO LAGA KI... ABHI ABHI MERA JANM HUA HAI, TERE AANE KI AAHAT, MERE DIL KI YE GHABRAHAT..., ROSHANI KA TUMHARE SATH AKAAR, KYA YE HAI MERE MAN KI PUKAR..., TU MUSKURAI MAI STABDH RAH GAYA, HAN MAIN BHI MUSKURAYA...... AUR MUJHE PYAR HO GAYA.... MAIN YE SONCHATA HE RAH GAYA... ISWAR AAJ SURYODAY KE ANTIM PAHAL ME, RASTA KYUN BHOOL GAYA..... IN ENGLISH WHEN I SAW YOU I FELT THAT I WAS BORN JUST NOW, THE FEAR OF YOUR ARRIVAL, THE FEAR OF MY HEART, THE LIGHT WITH YOU, IS THIS THE CALL OF MY HEART...., YOU REMAINED STILL IN SMILE, YES I ALSO SMILED IN LOVE I HAVE BEEN THINKING THAT WHY DID GOD FORGET THIS WAY IN THE LAST MOMENT OF SUN.....

HATE SPEECH IS NOT A LITTLE BIT SPARKLE......IS N'T IT ?

WHAT DO YOU MEAN BY A HATE SPEECH There is no specific legal definition of ‘hate speech’. Provisions in law criminalise speeches, writings, actions, signs and representations that foment violence and spread disharmony between communities and groups and these are understood to refer to ‘hate speech’. The Law Commission of India, in its 267th Report, says: “Hate speech generally is an incitement to hatred primarily against a group of persons defined in terms of race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, religious belief and the like ... Thus, hate speech is any word written or spoken, signs, visible representations within the hearing or sight of a person with the intention to cause fear or alarm, or incitement to violence.” In general, hate speech is considered a limitation on free speech that seeks to prevent or bar speech that exposes a person or a group or section of society to hate, violence, ridicule or indignity. CONTEXT A recent religious conclave held in Haridwar...

GLOBAL HEALTH PROFILE VULNERABILITY.......

THE ONGOING GLOBAL HEALTH EMERGENCY HAS PARALYSED ECONOMIES WORLDWIDE AND REVEALED THAT THE HEALTH SYSTEMS IN MOST COUNTRIES ARE UNDER-PREPARED TO COPE WITH ANY MAJOR HEALTH EMERGENCY. It has posed large-scale health challenges as millions of people (172,430,557 as on 3 June 2021) have been infected and lakhs of casualties (3,706,682 as on 3 June 2021) have occurred. The importance of public health does not need elucidation as the pandemic has revealed that inadequate attention to public health can have disastrous consequences on the masses. High-income countries such as Canada, Sweden and Germany, despite their exceptional public health systems, have had to struggle to contain the pandemic by experimenting with a number of uncertain alternatives. Understandably, the struggle for middle and low-income countries, having weak public healthcare systems, limited finances and large populations has been grim. India too, has been grappling with the pandemic and the ...

ACTUAL FEELING OF SOLVING REAL.......

to prepare you to face Aasma hai behad khoobsoorat, Rangaeen roshni aa rahi hai falak pe..... Sampoorn dharatal hai bheega, Jeevan ke pahar mein Ambar bhi mahak raha, Vasudha ke upvan mein Chintan mein hai dhara, Aas lagaye sunya se, Milogi mujhe ya rah jaogi chitiz mein...... IN ENGLISH The sky is very beautiful, Colorful light coming on the sky.... It's complete strike, It will be wet in the mountain of life, The sky is also fragrant(garden) in the wake of vasudha (earth), The river is in the thoughts. Hope you will meet sunya(sky) or you will remain in the chitiz(at the location where sky and earth will meet)............ SKY MEANS SOMEONE ELSE EARTH MEANS MYSELF.

VAGUENESS IN FEDERALISM......

Chhattisgarh Chief Minister Bhupesh Baghel and Rajasthan Chief Minister Ashok Gehlot on Friday wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi opposing the proposed amendments to the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre) Rules 1954. The proposed amendments will give overriding powers to the Union government to post All India Services (AIS) officers such as the IAS, the Indian Police Service and the Indian Forest Service (IFoS) to Central Ministries and departments without the State government’s nod. Mr. Baghel and Mr. Gehlot are second in line after West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee to convey their opposition against the proposed amendments to Mr. Modi. Sense of ‘instability’ Mr. Baghel said the amendments could be misused and “a sense of instability and ambiguity is likely to arise among the officers of the All India Services, who are posted at various important posts in various districts and also at the State level.” He said the proposed amendment granted the Centra...

TOURISM IS THE NEED OF HOUR WHY ?

BIG QUESTION There is an awareness in the government that the absence of tourist infrastructure is a major reason why India loses out to Southeast Asia. India has a vast basket of living and diverse cultural traditions, Traditional expressions, intangible cultural heritage comprising masterpieces which need institutional support and encouragement with a view to addressing areas critical for the survival and propagation of these forms of cultural heritage. Preserving our heritage is enshrined as a Fundamental Duty in our Constitution . STEPS HAVE BEEN TAKEN Prime Minister Narendra Modi recently inaugurated the Kushinagar international airport. ● The airport in eastern UP, the third international airport in the election-bound state, will mainly service the Buddhist tourism circuit. ● The Sri Lankan Airlines flight carrying monks and dignitaries was the first to land at the airport. st Asian nations such as Indon...

first ever scientific bird atlas......

The Kerala Bird Atlas (KBA), the first-of-its-kind State-level bird atlas in India, has created solid baseline data about the distribution and abundance of bird species across all major habitats, giving an impetus to futuristic studies. Conducted as a citizen science-driven exercise with the participation of over 1,000 volunteers of the birdwatching community, the KBA has been prepared based on systematic surveys held twice over 60 days a year during the wet (July to September) and dry (January to March) seasons between 2015 and 2020. The KBA accounts for nearly three lakh records of 361 species, including 94 very rare species, 103 rare species, 110 common species, 44 very common species, and 10 most abundant species. “The KBA offers authentic, consistent and comparable data through random sampling from the geographical terrain split into nearly 4,000 grids. We are in the process of bringing out papers on interesting trends based on a scientific analysis of solid dat...

The Budget spells green shoots for agri-subsectors

At the time it was presented, and in the context of the Assembly elections in five States — now underway in Uttar Pradesh, Punjab, Uttarakhand, Manipur and Goa https://sites.google.com/view/insightsdev/home the Union Budget was expected to contain measures to boost consumption expenditure. But the Government chose instead to focus more on capital expenditure. There were no major announcements on agriculture or rural development. Given the recent turmoil as a result of the farmers’ protests and the repeal of the farm laws, this was a little surprising. However, a closer look at the Budget presents a different picture. Allotments, key subsectors It is important to look at the budgetary allocations for agriculture from the perspective of agricultural growth and farmers’ income. Agriculture has registered a robust performance during the COVID-19 pandemic and has clocked decent growth rates of 4.3% and 3.6% during 2019-20 and 2020-21. Growth is projected to be about 3.9% i...

MONEY LAUNDERING........The despotic nature of the PMLA

The draconian PMLA of 2002 has evolved as the Government’s “hatchet” law in recent years, considering the series of raids and arrests of politicians, their relatives, and activists, most of them who are critical of the ruling regime. The unease about the law has become so rife that a bunch of petitions filed by people across the country have questioned the almost blanket powers given to the ED through this law. The Act was enacted in a 2002 response to India’s global commitment (including the Vienna Convention) to combat the menace of money laundering, stemming from the trade of drugs and narcotics and the organised crime that goes with it. Lawyers argue that the PMLA is invoked against a political rival or a dissenter, because the “process is itself the punishment”. They point out that the ECIR, an equivalent of the FIR, is considered an “internal document” and not given to the accused. Which means that, pursuant to the registration of the ECIR, as the ED begins to...

PESTEL

Search This Blog